Showing posts with label Punchestown. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Punchestown. Show all posts

Monday, February 4, 2013

Supreme Novices Update: Moscow Flyer Novice Hurdle review


We find ourselves with only five weeks until the big day. Before you know it the Festival will have been and gone, leaving us with thoughts of the upcoming flat season. While Aintree will be an entertaining interlude, the prospect of the Cheltenham Festival ending is grim, to say the least. In reality that is still some way off, for all that it won’t feel that way once it arrives, and there are still trial races to digest and consider. One such trial was the Moscow Flyer Novice Hurdle at Punchestown on Sunday won last year by Trifolium, an unlucky third in the Supreme, and previously by Mikael D’Haguenet for Willie Mullins. Mullins won the race once again this season but it would be bold to predict a similarly authoritative display at Cheltenham from this year’s winner, Mozoltov.

Mozoltov was among the best Irish bumper horses last season despite being soundly beaten three times. His defeat at the hands of Clonbanan Lad may give an indication to what level he is capable of reaching in novice hurdles but that would be unfair. Mozoltov has always been highly regarded but he did not quite have the form to back up his reputation until he ran his best race during the Punchestown Festival, where he finished close to Melodic Rendezvous but a significant distance behind Champagne Fever. That looks a level below what is required for a Supreme, despite how strongly or otherwise Melodic Rendezvous is fancied. This weekend’s run also has the appearance of being a level or two below what will be required. On his first outing this season Mozoltov demolished an atrocious field divulging little about himself in the process, other than he could jump. Again on Sunday his hurdling was fluent and brisk and he consistently came away from the hurdles faster than his better fancied rival Don Cossack, even when Davy Russell found the right stride. Willie Mullins said afterwards that the Supreme would be his next race, perhaps surprising given that he had been slightly under the radar in terms of novice hurdlers. There has not been the same hype and talk about him that has befallen some of his stablemates and maybe it was naive not to enter him into one’s calculations for the Festival opener. Yet Mullins did say at the start of the season that Mozoltov was a chaser in the making and even after this weekend I would struggle to make a case for him winning at Cheltenham based on what he’s done, only on what he might do.

The beaten favourite on Sunday was Don Cossack. He is surely destined to be better over further and his jumping can only hold him back over smaller obstacles, particularly at this trip where speed is paramount and slick jumping is necessitated. However, he already proved that he was inferior to the current standard bearer over two-and-a-half miles, Pont Alexandre, last time at Navan and it is difficult to envisage him recreating that awesome impression he left in bumpers, while hurdling over the minimum trip. In bumpers Don Cossack took people’s imagination, he left an indelible, powerful mark leading many to assume his ascent to the top over obstacles would be swift. On debut this season, there was little to dissuade this notion other than a certain sloppiness in his hurdling technique, but the ground was lamentable and it could be quickly brushed aside by connections and onlookers. Unfortunately, next time out against the imperious Neptune bound Pont Alexandre the problem appeared more chronic. There was certainly improvement in that area on Sunday but not enough to suggest that he will reach the heights over hurdles that once seemed inevitable.

The faith shown in him by his talented trainer is tough, possibly foolish, to ignore. This season might appear disappointing when one considers what was expected but Gordon Elliott always maintained he was a future chaser from the top drawer and this is hard to refute especially when taking his physique and running style into account. He is a powerful galloper who gives too much air to his hurdles in the manner of a chaser, with fences between him and his goal there may be a different animal waiting to be unleashed. Don Cossack is not the novice hurdler that many had hoped for but the seemingly limitless potential that he possessed in bumpers could be fulfilled over fences once he begins the job he was bred for. When put into the perspective that Don Cossack is effectively a three mile chaser, his hurdling career to date has been far from underwhelming.

Ned Buntline is another well regarded novice but of the well-fancied triumvirate at Punchestown he was the most disappointing. McCoy was at pains to hold him up right off the pace, his keen going tendencies were plain to see, but from last he moved stylishly into third following a big leap two out before fading relatively quickly as the front two quickened clear. Ned Buntline has not looked devoid of pace in his career, hence it could be that he struggled with the ground, failing to pick up as well as his rider might have expected. There will be improvement to come on a sounder surface but this display arguably rules out enough improvement to get competitive in what looks a competitive Supreme and it is possible to say that he, to some extent, holds the form down for the first and second.  A convincing win over Urano (subsequently beaten by the lesser known Legal Exit) on his last run prior to this weekend, Ned Buntline was back on track having shocked connections previously when beaten by Bright New Dawn at Fairyhouse. But, while an extremely useful and still somewhat unexposed novice hurdler, Bright New Dawn was comfortably dispatched by Jezki, current favourite for the Supreme, on his next start. Jessica Harrington’s five-year-old was unextended and Ned Buntline’s conqueror was all of eight lengths behind. Once his chance was gone Ned Buntline was caringly handled by McCoy here and he was only beaten six-and-a-half-lengths. If Mozoltov or even Don Cossack had pretensions on the Supreme crown they needed to pull further clear. The way Jezki has finished off his races over hurdles indicates that we are someway off seeing his limit whereas Mozoltov was all out to see off Don Cossack.

Willie Mullins’ charge may prove to be better than this, with Ruby Walsh suggesting afterwards that he wasn’t entirely enjoying the ground but he has only run so far on soft or heavy ground and his best performance, up until this weekend, had been on essentially unraceable ground at the Punchestown Festival. I wouldn’t be desperate to suggest that he will improve for the quicker ground normally prevalent at Cheltenham. Mozoltov may improve for the faster pace and bigger field in the Supreme, he was ridden quite aggressively at Punchestown and could be more impressive were he to be held up off a stronger gallop, but it is all about how much and while his price may appear tempting on the face of it now, once we have seen next weekend’s events it may well look on the mean side.

Monday, February 6, 2012

Supreme Novices Update: Trifolium

During an exceptional weekend of sport one performance may have gone under the radar.  Arsenal’s super seven against Blackburn, Manchester United’s comeback at Stamford Bridge, the titanic tussle between Wales and Ireland in the Six Nations, the Giants’ victory in the Super Bowl and even the demolition of Big Zeb by Sizing Europe all overshadowed Trifolium’s win at Punchestown which has put him right into the Supreme Novices picture. Although with the absence of jump racing in Britain it’s possible many will have been focussed on the Irish racing more than ever.

Trifolium is a more experienced hurdler than most of his likely Supreme rivals. He has already run six times but importantly he seems to have a progressive profile.  On his first two starts in Ireland he ran extremely promising races and was placed on both occasions. Each time he was keen and finished relatively weakly. Accounting for this, his connections decided on a set of cheek pieces and a change in tactics on his next start at Cork where he was allowed to get on with it. Making all, he never saw another rival and in the end pulled, an eye-catching, 24 lengths clear. This change in tactics looked the way to go and next time out he set off in front again. Once more he won comfortably, never off the bridle, beating handicapper Plan A by just over 8 lengths. Trifolium appeared to cope well with the small field on his first start out of novice company so his trainer targeted a similar type of race at Navan for his next run. This time he faced a far sterner test up against one of last season’s top novices So Young.

Trained by the phenomenon that is Willie Mullins, So Young has been talked up as a possible challenger to Big Buck’s over 3 miles this season but on this occasion he stuck to two miles on testing ground. With such a formidable opponent it was always going to be tough and So Young was clearly expected to win as he was sent off at 1/3. He duly did and won well, with Trifolium 7½ lengths behind. On bare form this was another promising run but, in reality it was somewhat disappointing. Intriguingly, the evidently successful front-running tactics weren't employed this time on Trifolium, thereby handing the initiative to the masterful Ruby Walsh. It is possible they were worried about the son of Godneyev’s tendency to be keen and they were hoping to teach him to settle with a view to the festival where it is extremely difficult to win from the front. However, yet again Trifolium took a very keen hold and for the first half of the race Charles Byrne’s charge was fighting with jockey Davy Russell, but surprisingly between the third and second last he looked to be travelling better than So Young. For a second an upset was on the cards, but his early exertions had cost him as Trifolium had nothing more to give when So Young quickened away after the two out. This was to some extent understandable given the strong gallop set by Ruby Walsh on the soft-heavy ground. In spite of this his propensity to pull was alarming for a Cheltenham Festival aspirant and Charles Byrnes was keen himself to give the 5 year old one more run for experience.  

At Punchestown on Sunday they again decided to take a lead but this time he settled noticeably better and travelled smoothly throughout before an ultra impressive turn of foot approaching the home bend put the race to bed, only having to ridden out hands and heels to finish, a more than, convincing 9 lengths clear of another Mullins trained adversary Simenon. This was back in novice company and he was strongly fancied to win, sent off a 7/4 favourite, but nonetheless it was a tremendous display.

This performance would suggest he has a huge chance in the Supreme Novices Hurdle in March. Ever since the cheek pieces were applied his jumping has been assured and it was particularly good on Sunday. He also displayed the necessary pace for the festival curtain raiser and two miles looks to be his trip at this stage. Bearing all this in mind, the 16/1 available for Trifolium looks a fair price and it would be difficult to dissuade anyone from taking it. However, all his best runs over hurdles so far have come on soft or heavy ground and the way he powered through it at Punchestown suggests he relishes the surface. His trainer stated after the race he would improve for better ground and if this was true then he would have every chance in March, but I have my doubts. What he achieved in winning by 9 lengths is also debatable. Simenon had won a very weak maiden at Cork previously and possibly wants further than two miles and Joxer, who looked to be Trifolium’s main rival before the race, made two terrible mistakes, when still going well, at the third and second last flight effectively ending his chances. I feel the race was not a strong one and Trifolium will have to improve again if he is to challenge at Cheltenham especially when you think that the only time he faced a top class rival he was beaten comfortably, albeit with excuses. These excuses mainly revolved around his inability to settle and while he was fine on Sunday it would still be a major worry for me. Even Davy Russell said after the race at Punchestown that he worried about his keen going nature for Cheltenham and his not sure the track will suit. My final concern would surround his owners Gigginstown House Stud. They already have Midnight Game (Willie Mullins) who looks a better candidate for the Supreme Novices and is shorter in the in the betting. Second guessing them is always difficult but he looks their number one and with worries over the track suiting Trifolium you cannot be sure he will even turn up at Cheltenham.