Supreme Novices Update: Douvan

http://www.cheltenhamzone.com/reviews/supreme-corner-douvan-delivers-moscow-flyer/

Supreme Novices Update: Vaniteux, Vautour and Rathvinden

It is possible this week had little bearing on the Supreme Novices’ in March. Unlike with last week’s Grade 1 Royal Bond there were no ‘trials’ to speak of for the two milers while the Neptune was well catered for. Faugheen looks to be heading that way after his saunter round Navan, but were he to drop back to two miles the Supreme would be a realistic target given the impression he has made despite his inexperience.

In England, Vaniteux’s display at Sandown was perhaps the most meaningful in Supreme terms. He readily saw off second season novice Vibrato Valtat, who had shaped well in a fiercely competitive novice handicap at Cheltenham on his seasonal reappearance, and the pair came clear of the third Champagne At Tara, Jonjo O’Neill’s well-regarded prospect who had finished fourth in a hot Cheltenham bumper on his previous start. Vaniteux, now in the care of Nicky Henderson having acquitted himself adequately in two point-to-points, hurdled fluently throughout the contest until the second last where a not insignificant error knocked him back on his heels as he was about to join the lead. He had to be vigorously ridden to assert late on but once he did the victory appeared almost emphatic, as Vibrato Valtat had no response to his rival’s superior stamina and ability. Without the mishap at the penultimate flight Vaniteux would have run out an even more taking winner. His jumping, on the evidence of one run of course, is accomplished, albeit clearly not infallible, and he is blessed with more speed than one might expect from a gelding with his background. This son of eminent, but sadly departed, stallion Voix Du Nord possesses the right mix of attributes to make a talented two mile novice hurdler though probably not at the level required for a Supreme contender. Even accounting for the late blunder, Vaniteux should have dispatched the formerly disappointing juvenile Vibrato Valtat if he has graded Festival aspirations. The distance back to Champagne At Tara may be cause for encouragement, he has shown the potential to make it at a higher grade, but he was never really put into the race on Saturday with future targets over further almost certainly in mind.  At this stage Nicky Henderson also has other, more viable candidates for the Supreme, a factor which could see this four-year-old targeted elsewhere.

Another trainer with no shortage of viable candidates, some would say a plethora, is Willie Mullins. He gets stronger in the novice hurdling department by the week and the depth of his squad is such that arguably his best novice hurdlers, like the aforementioned Faugheen and Champion Bumper winner Briar Hill, could avoid the Supreme. This weekend Mullins unleashed two more exciting types over hurdles and it is difficult to decide who was more impressive, Vautour or Rathvinden. Of the two, Vautour is the only one quoted for the Supreme and his smooth success in the four-year-olds only contest at Navan on Saturday marks him out as one to take seriously. His hurdling experience in France stood him in good stead here as his jumping was quick and accurate and he settled immediately. His experience gave him an advantage over many but even so he still had far too much for this field as, with the most minimal of urgings, he cruised clear from the last. Often maiden hurdles of this type are big on numbers but low on quality outside of one standout, however on this occasion Vautour may have beaten some reasonable novices. The second and fourth had both won Punchestown bumpers while the third had won his only other race in France. The first four in this field have potential in this realm; it is unlikely to be a case of Willie Mullins’ charge beating ‘nothing’.

Willie Mullins has done particularly well with the progeny of Robin Des Champs and Vautour is another. He has always been held in high esteem and plenty was expected of him despite being beaten on his two starts in France. Both those defeats came on heavy and it is likely he improved for better ground faced at Navan, as offspring of this sire often do. We will inevitably learn more about his ability as he rises in class but it is hard to imagine he won’t be able to cope against the more established Irish novices and it will be interesting to see what his conqueror on his final French start, Black River, achieves once given another opportunity by Paul Nicholls, having fallen at Newbury. There are very few things to hold against Vautour, his hurdling is sound and effective, he settles nicely, has the speed for two miles and handles any ground with preference for a quicker surface, akin to one he would probably face at Cheltenham. Like nearly everything at the Mullins base in Closutton he is one to be positive about, as for a Supreme bid? We will just have to wait for Willie’s plans.  

It would be nice to think Rathvinden will be among those plans as he races in the colours of Ronnie Bartlett, colours that would have already been carried to victory in the Supreme had connections made the right decision with Simonsig (although saying the Neptune was the wrong decision would be ridiculous). The five-year-old son of Heron Island came from the same source as Simonsig, Northern Irish trainer Ian Ferguson. Bartlett bought the horse following a resounding success at Downpatrick in June. The race was only a lady riders’ bumper but one can imagine Ferguson recommending the gelding to his new owner and Rathvinden was soon in the care of Willie Mullins. The plan had been to go straight over hurdles yet his work had been so good they went for a bumper under a penalty at Cork. Settled in second for most of the way he travelled strongly until two out where he was shaken up and a sharp turn-of-foot saw he burst clear. That was a striking twelve length win for his new trainer and he was sent back over course and distance on Sunday to do the same again, this time over obstacles. His jumping was more than sufficient if not, understandably, as confident as Vautour’s and, having hugged the inside in behind the leaders for the rest of the contest, he was switched out as he approached the third last at which a brave jump saw him hit the front. The race was as good as over at that point as his rider Paul Townend, the only one not hard at work, looked round for non-existent dangers. His notable acceleration reappeared as he put distance between him and those toiling in behind.

Rathvinden was barely shaken up here over two miles and produced no shortage of speed. Whether this will prove his optimal trip this season is debatable. I feel he looks at home over two miles but then the opposition he has taken on has been rather lacking. His acceleration might be too easy to overplay given the limitations of those in behind and he is seeing out his races well enough not to have any concerns about an increase in distance. In fact, the Downpatrick Ladies race was over two-and-a-quarter miles, whilst he fell at the last when with every chance over three miles in his only point. Rathvinden is just quoted for the Neptune at the Festival and a step up in trip might be inescapable but, much like Simonsig, I would be keen to see him tested against better rivals over the minimum trip.

Supreme Novices Update: Minella Foru & Very Wood

To lose their chance at Festival glory in the most exciting race of them all (arguably) on the day before the race must have been agonising for the connections of Melodic Rendezvous. His season had been carefully orchestrated by Jeremy Scott and he was among the leading contenders for the Supreme until fate intervened. Last season, despite not getting the opportunity to prove me right or wrong, I suspect I was guilty of underrating Melodic Rendezvous. The horses he beat often appeared to have valid excuses and I struggled to get too excited about him but in reality he was a rapidly progressing novice set to peak for Cheltenham. His performance at Wincanton on Saturday certainly gave an indication of what he might have achieved had he made it to the start. Defeating a fully fit Far West in that manner was hugely impressive and I will try not to underestimate him in future. This season, Minella Foru might fit into the same mould as Melodic Rendezvous in that he is easy to underrate and excuses for his main rival on Sunday were evident for all to see.   

Minella Foru began his hurdling career in good style at Listowel, having previously taken the eye of point-to-point followers at Lemonfield, yet despite Eddie Harty not hiding the regard in which he is held the four-year-old was still trumped in the Navan market on Sunday by Gigginstown’s exciting prospect, Very Wood. The pace set by the market leader was ponderous at best, but Minella Foru dealt with it well. He was keen but not in a way that would prove detrimental to his chances, while his jumping was little short of ideal for a two mile novice hurdler. There was barely a semblance of a mistake, so swift over the obstacles; he hurdled with a fluency that was all the more striking given the leader’s antics. As the pace quickened from the third last, Minella Foru responded willingly to his rider AP McCoy’s urgings, picking up well to reach and pass Very Wood. This performance showed off plenty of Minella Foru’s assets, particularly his speed which will serve him well as he steps up in class but as a contest the race was somewhat unsatisfactory and his superiority over the second, at the line, could be misleading.

Very Wood was among a batch of point-to-pointers who were trained by Gordon Elliott before being sent elsewhere for their novice hurdle careers. Following a narrow defeat in his first point-to-point, Very Wood took his second in style defeating Champagne Tara, a bumper winner for Jonjo O’Neill since, by four lengths. Before losing him for this season, Elliott ran him in a lucrative Punchestown Festival bumper in which he again ran out an easy winner. One could not help but look forward to his future over obstacles after that and, having moved to Noel Meade, he delivered what many expected on his hurdling debut at Galway. Davy Russell gradually wound the race up from the front pulling nicely clear of the second and a long way clear of the third. He shaped like a relentless galloper on this occasion with a step up in trip looking inevitable. Noel Meade clearly didn’t share that view, deciding instead to stick to two miles on Sunday. There was enough to take from his previous run to suggest he could remain successful over the minimum trip, assuming he could gallop his rivals into submission. Very Wood’s jumping around the right-handed Galway was adequate, with no causes for concern, and connections were confident of a smart performance.

If Minella Foru is a serious candidate for the Supreme Novices’ Hurdle then going down a length-and-a-half was a smart performance for a horse like Very Wood who is a classic Gigginstown prospect, unlikely to reach his full potential until he sees three miles and fences. Very Wood and Minella Foru are different types of horses and the sprint for home would have suited the former far less than the latter. Davy Russell, making the running on Very Wood, had the opportunity to set a real test but his mount did very little to help their cause. He lugged right from the start, jumped out to the right at each hurdle, with varying degrees of severity, and even struggled to navigate some of the left-handed bends. He must have given away a significant amount of ground to his rivals and it is tempting to think that without the wayward tendencies or on a right-handed track, he would have come out on top. However, it also the case that Very Wood was better placed for the sprint finish, than the resulting winner, having had his own way out in front. While AP McCoy, renowned for his strength in a finish when necessary, was hardly all out to settle matters aboard Minella Foru.

Such was the farcical nature of the race it is difficult to draw too many conclusions about the respective merits of the front two. In terms of the Supreme, Very Wood was always more likely to excel over further and, now there appears to be a problem with left-handed tracks, connections may already be looking past Cheltenham to Punchestown for their long term targets. I am trying to keep an open mind with regards to Minella Foru. There is the slight possibility that Very Wood is exceptional and Minella Foru did well to beat him but if he wants to become a top two mile novice he would have to beat a stayer like Very Wood in this manner especially considering the circumstances. Eddie Harty has suggested that his next run will be in the Royal Bond Novice Hurdle on December 1 or the Future Champions Novice Hurdle at Leopardstown's Christmas meeting. Either way we will learn more about his Supreme credentials then as he takes on the best available in Ireland. Despite his precise jumping and rare natural speed the likelihood of meeting rivals from higher profile yards means he may well be underestimated again.

Supreme Novices Update 2013/14 so far

The long road to Cheltenham has begun in earnest once again. While a drier summer than usual has led to many of jump racing’s big guns being behind schedule, we could well have seen a number of this season’s Festival winners already. Whether the winner of the Supreme Novices’ Hurdle is among them is questionable.

There have been notable performances from horses with realistic Supreme aspirations, although mainly in Ireland where the season gets going earlier. Minella Foru, a winner of a particularly competitive point-to-point at Lemonfield, made his hurdling debut in September. He jumped well and posted a cosy victory over a strongly fancied, Willie Mullins trained French import. Mullins will know where he stands with Minella Foru given his enviable abundance of novice hurdle talent but Eddie Harty’s four-year-old has considerable capacity for improvement, for all that he has a long way to go to be the next Captain Cee Bee.

Carriganog was Aidan O’Brien’s first runner over hurdles for some time. Subsequent to an underwhelming career in bumpers, he was sent to Robbie Power over the summer in order to teach him how to jump and this son of Shantou delivered two fluent successes hinting at bigger things. The form of those in behind Carriganog amounts to very little and he is already being spoken of as a chaser but his quick hurdling technique and extraordinary trainer make it difficult to surmise just what level he can reach this season.  

Working out which of Willie Mullins’ bumper horses to concentrate on in terms of the Supreme is hard enough before factoring in the inevitable imports from the continent and the flat. One such import is Arctic Fire who received quotes for the Festival opener following his striking Irish debut at Tipperary. Slick jumping and a decisive turn-of-foot between the last two flights separated him from his inferior rivals, attributes which bode well for the future. His trainer has so many options in this division that it would almost be imprudent to earmark any for a particular Festival target but Arctic Fire is one candidate for Willie Mullins who should not be required to step up in trip.

The most interesting novice hurdle over two miles this season and the race most likely to have a bearing on the Cheltenham Festival curtain raiser in March did come this side of the Irish Sea at Aintree on Saturday. Despite Champion Bumper winner, Briar Hill heading numerous ante-post lists for the Supreme, the way he shaped in bumpers and his pedigree point towards a hurdling campaign over longer distances. As such, for many the obvious next port of call for this season’s Supreme Novices’ Hurdle winner was Champion Bumper runner-up, Regal Encore. Having reportedly schooled well, Saturday’s return to action was eagerly anticipated and there was enough confidence behind him to be sent off the 8/15 favourite.

Settled in rear by McCoy, who may have expected or at least hoped for a stronger pace, Regal Encore travelled strongly to three out, having moved wide on the final turn in for home. Then, probably with education in mind, McCoy was keen to find cover for much of the straight and only asked for a serious effort as they approached the last. Regal Encore had already made up significant ground to get into contention at the last but the winner of the race, Garde La Victoire, had been given too much rope. McCoy quickly accepted that they were unable to reach the leader and was far from hard on the son of Kings Theatre who stayed on encouragingly, gradually closing the gap to the winner on the run in.

For one among the best in the bumper sphere last season this might be seen as a disappointing defeat for Anthony Honeyball’s charge, but there is no reason to write off Regal Encore as a Supreme candidate yet. At Aintree he appeared to be outpaced by the winner, merely staying on too late as if in need of further. A step up to two-and-a-half miles would be unlikely to cause him a problem yet I get the sense a fast run two miles will prove his optimum for the time being and the Supreme is often a race for strong stayers. His jumping on Saturday was accurate and with further experience, as well as a more aggressive ride, it is not difficult to foresee the form being reversed.

There was enough to take from this race to be excited about his future and the performance was reminiscent of My Tent Or Yours’ defeat at the hands of Chatterbox last season. Concerned about the soft ground at Newbury, on a horse who was particularly difficult to settle at the time, McCoy was at pains to hold My Tent Or Yours up for as long as he could in order to avoid a hard race with future targets in mind. One of those future targets was the Betfair Hurdle back at Newbury in February, which he won in handsome fashion. It is a race that could well suit Regal Encore in time, especially given the likely progress he will make between now and then after this pleasing introduction to hurdles.

Based largely on last season’s achievements, the runner-up on Saturday still seems the more appealing prospect for the Supreme Novices’ Hurdle but that might be doing a disservice to the aforementioned winner, Garde La Victoire. Following a convincing victory in a junior bumper at Exeter last October, numerous factors contributed to his absence from the racecourse until this weekend. The son of Kapgarde was understandably underestimated having come into the race off just one run in moderate company. Having been so difficult to assess before the race, it is evident afterwards that he is a talented novice hurdler. This powerful looking individual pulled hard from the outset but Richard Johnson was able to retain his position just in behind the leaders before an impressive leap at the fourth last took him to the front. He had jumped well up until that point, displaying a reassuring aptitude for hurdles. However, once left alone in the home straight he lost concentration, becoming clumsy at the last three flights, offering a glimmer of hope to the favourite in pursuit. Nevertheless, Garde La Victoire’s laudable attitude allowed him to maintain his advantage as he put his head down and galloped all the way to the line.

This four-year-old has scope in abundance and given his hard-pulling tendencies, two miles will surely be his ideal trip. Hence, were he to make a top novice hurdler this season, his Festival target would be the Supreme, something that can be said for very few exciting prospects this season. His trainer Philip Hobbs knows what it takes to win the race, taking the prize with Menorah in 2010, and if they can curtail his free-going nature he may well pose a threat on the day. From what little evidence we have of him, Garde La Victoire looks ready made for fences and I suggest that is where his future lies. Therefore, were he to make it to Cheltenham in March as a leading contender it would be a surprise, but certainly not an unwelcome one.

Supreme Novices’ Hurdle Prediction: 1-2-3

Despite the incessant reading, listening, tweeting and thinking about Cheltenham, it is somewhat hard to believe that the Festival has all but arrived. Throughout the season I have tried to set out my views on the key trials for the Supreme, detailing how the possible contenders have shaped and hopefully pointing out reasons for and against supporting each horse in advance of the big race next week. It should have become clear who I am keenest on but just in case, now seems the right time to definitively predict the result. Here are the three I fancy to finish first, second and third:

3^rd – Champagne Fever

With the strongest Irish form available it might seem foolish to leave Jezki out of the top three, especially when he has already beaten the third place selection in the Royal Bond Novice Hurdle. Despite doing all that has been asked of him this season, there are reasons to think Jezki will not achieve at Cheltenham what many people are expecting. His emphatic victory at Leopardstown last time forced many to sit up and take notice of this son of Milan but the form has since been let down by Waaheb who during that race at Leopardstown made a horrendous blunder thereby exaggerating the winning distance. There are still concerns about Jezki’s jumping, despite showing significant improvement travelling left-handed, and the good ground he apparently needs to be seen at his best is not materialising. He may, on the face of it, standout as a solid each-way play, but despite preferring to see Jezki’s last run at Cheltenham as largely irrelevant, the way he faded up the hill behind Champagne Fever continues to niggle. The received wisdom is that Willie Mullins’ gangly grey lacks the speed for two miles and the late wavering over his target, between this and the three mile Albert Bartlett, can only be a negative. However, he managed to hold off much ‘faster’ rivals in the Champion Bumper when there were similar concerns and the recent rain will help, he could prove just as hard to pass at Cheltenham over hurdles. I suspect he will lack the speed to win this race but he still looks capable of finishing in the frame. There will likely come a point in the race where he looks sure to be swamped, yet his jumping is good and bold enough to keep him in front for a long way, while his class should help him see off a number of overrated rivals. More than three horses could easily pass Champagne Fever, but such is his abundant stamina, I can see the speedier contenders trying to compete with My Tent Or Yours’ turn of foot and failing, finishing tired, while the stoutly bred son of Stowaway flies up the hill, snatching a place.

2^nd – My Tent Or Yours

Recent defeats for heavily backed, short priced favourites in the Supreme should not be a reason to oppose My Tent Or Yours. He was sensationally impressive in the Betfair Hurdle at Newbury, with three progressive young handicappers making the frame. Nothing in behind can be used to hold the form down, so in a misguided attempt to crab the performance, a slow pace and a beneficially prominent ride have been given as reasons to knock My Tent Or Yours. If anything, I expect a faster pace would have seen Nicky Henderson’s charge appear even more imperious, given his tendency to pull hard. Some have even questioned what My Tent Or Yours finds off the bridle since his Newbury rout. Well from what I could see about ten lengths, but that is debatable, what isn’t debatable is the amount he found to beat subsequent Grade 1 winning hurdler Taquin Du Seuil on hurdling debut, having jumped atrociously. That is no longer an issue with the Desert Prince gelding; his hurdling was electric in the twenty one runner Betfair Hurdle. He is developing rapidly and it would have been no surprise to see My Tent Or Yours run in the Champion Hurdle. In my opinion, this speedster is nearly bombproof as favourite and he has never struck me as being a particularly short price. I will be shocked if, barring injury, incident or illness, My Tent Or Yours does not finish in the first two on Tuesday. Consequently, it might be more sensible to select him as my winner given that I can easily envisage him taking the Festival curtain raiser in a similar fashion to the Betfair Hurdle, but there is a chance another is better and that is a chance I am willing to take.

1^st – Un Atout

The only horse in the field that I can imagine matching or bettering My Tent Or Yours is Un Atout. There was barely a more impressive, jaw-dropping bumper performance during the 2011/2012 season and his hurdling debut this time around was eagerly anticipated. Yet again he mastered his rivals with little effort, dominating the race from the front. The level of opposition he faced at Navan is questionable and the two horses that could have given a level to the form have been deprived the chance of boosting it since; with the fourth, Some Article, being carried out next time, and the second, Fickle Fortune, subsequently suffering a season ending injury. Fickle Fortune herself was an extremely pacey horse in bumpers, thus giving encouragement to those who felt Un Atout would have the speed for grade 1 races over two miles. This was despite the immediate post race comments from his trainer suggesting he is a prospective staying chaser. His jumping on debut was occasionally big, possibly giving rise to those comments, but he was accurate and fast on his next start and Davy Russell has been effusive with praise for his jumping since. Un Atout destroyed his field here, at Naas, on the bridle and he became the serious Supreme contender he is now with Willie Mullins making it clear afterwards that he was content to keep this imposing son of Robin Des Champs at two miles. This was another piece of form potentially lacking strength, with the unreliable Rory O’Moore finishing nineteen lengths away in second. The third though, Art Of Logistics, has won since at Fairyhouse, defeating the aforementioned, and still highly regarded, Waaheb, in the process. The ground at Naas was very deep and Art Of Logistics may not have handled it but the form boost he delivered at least gives substance to Un Atout’s unparalleled style.

He did miss his next intended engagement in the Deloitte due to a sub standard piece of work and even his most ardent fans have to acknowledge his lack of experience; the pace of the race, the ground, the atmosphere and the crowd at Prestbury Park will all be new to him. But he has shown no sign of temperament in his three runs so far, he is a relaxed individual and I would be confident that he will take everything in his powerful stride. The faster pace and the potential emphasis on stamina created by the likes of his stablemate Champagne Fever should suit, while there is still scope for him to improve on the quicker surface at Cheltenham. The Festival will almost certainly start on soft but it will be far removed from the deep, heavy ground Un Atout has faced runs over hurdles up to now.

This will be a truly hot renewal of the Supreme but at Willie Mullins' Closutton base Un Atout is housed in an elite group of three along with Sir Des Champs and Hurricane Fly, and I fancy he can match his illustrious neighbours' success at the Cheltenham Festival in this, the most anticipated race of the year.

1. Un Atout
2. My Tent Or Yours
3. Champagne Fever

Supreme Novices Update: My Tent Or Yours, Champagne Fever and Melodic Rendezvous

Betfair’s Super Saturday at Newbury lost some of its lustre with the decisions not to run Long Run or Simonsig in their respective prep races for the Festival. This left the card without a serious Arkle/Champion Chase contender and Silviniaco Conti with a seemingly straightforward task in the Denman Chase. Racing is rarely as simple as that though and it delivered more than enough excitement to make up for Nicky Henderson’s cautiousness. Ironically it was Henderson’s own My Tent Or Yours who really lit up Saturday’s card and the whole weekend. Prior to the Betfair Hurdle My Tent Or Yours was a rare beast in that his Cheltenham target was inevitable, evident from a very early stage, well it was until he did that!

After his scintillating display on Saturday My Tent Or Yours is quite rightly being talked up as a Champion Hurdle horse and he would not be out of place in that field, rather a deserved leading contender. The one issue left with Nicky Henderson’s charge, having sorted out his jumping at Huntingdon, was his free-going nature. He had been over-exuberant and keen in each run so far, the concern being whether he could find enough off the bridle after using up so much energy in a race against higher quality opposition. This frailty was harshly exposed by The New One in last season’s exceptional renewal of the Aintree Bumper. My Tent Or Yours is a better, stronger individual now but this was still a minor worry in a ‘competitive’ race like the Betfair Hurdle. As such I expected him to be settled in rear and pick off the other runners one by one, much like he had tried and failed to do on his last visit to Newbury. Maybe in the knowledge that there were few, if any, horses involved willing to set the pace or maybe just with supreme confidence AP McCoy crossed the tape, near enough, in front. From then on it was McCoy’s mission to settle him, My Tent Or Yours still pulled against his rider but McCoy was able drop him back as they left the home straight for the first time. In a seemingly ideal position on the inside rail, McCoy was in search of cover all the way up the back straight, just making sure he could keep a lid on all the enthusiasm and speed underneath him. As the field entered the home straight My Tent Or Yours had moved up into fifth and as commentator Richard Hoiles pointed out it was plain to see that McCoy was intent on slipstreaming the mare, Swing Bowler, for as long as he could. As the leaders drew away from the third last My Tent Or Yours was still pulling as he latched right onto the tail of Swing Bowler, before moving out to jump the second last. At that moment there was only one horse catching the eye and it became a matter of how far. Finally let go by McCoy at the last, the Desert Prince gelding rapped the hurdle as his acceleration got the better of him before powering clear under hands and heels, eventually easing down to a five length victory.

There is little more that he could have done here, his jumping was neat and fast, particularly at the second where he was unsighted thereby forcing him in close to the hurdle but he was extraordinarily nimble over it, thanks in no small part, I am sure, to AP McCoy’s intensive schooling. My Tent Or Yours found plenty off the bridle, putting an eight or nine length gap on the field as he was let down, before being eased. Despite the steady pace set the form could not look much stronger, with nothing in there holding it down and three thoroughly progressive handicappers filling the places. Cotton Mill had been well fancied for this, primarily on the back of his run in the Neptune where he was travelling nearly as well as Simonsig at the second last before running out in spectacular fashion. His impressive performance here does make the decision to run Cotton Mill over three miles straight after his Cheltenham calamity seem somewhat perplexing and with connections' desire to avoid heavy ground at all costs, the rain, sleet and snow which greeted us at Newbury on Saturday can’t have benefitted him. Neither was the race run especially to suit as he would have preferred a stronger pace, he lacked the speed of the winner, but then most jumpers do, and arguably Swing Bowler before his stamina kicked in, finishing strongly into second. There is clearly more to come, even before taking into account that this was his first run for 302 days, and he is an exciting prospect wherever he goes. A trip to the Champion Hurdle would not be unthinkable and were My Tent Or Yours to revert to novice company he would be a fascinating barometer of the Betfair Hurdle form. This could well be one of the strongest handicap hurdles of the whole season and it must be wise to consider strongly the likes of Swing Bowler and Dark Lover for the County Hurdle, Village Vic for the Coral Cup and even Caid Du Berlais for the Fred Winter, having shown up well for a long way despite running wide and being out of the weights.

I am struggling to find any negatives around My Tent Or Yours' chances for the Supreme Novices Hurdle and he is a worthy favourite, having usurped fellow JP McManus purchase Jezki. Ominously for his rivals, My Tent Or Yours has shown that he handles testing conditions while he is likely to improve for a quicker surface. He just has so much pace and as I suggested after his last run there was nothing in the Betfair Hurdle that could live with him. The only question left for me about My Tent Or Yours is whether something like the completely unexposed Un Atout is better, although the question that might prove more pertinent in the lead up to the Cheltenham Festival is whether it is Un Atout’s fellow Closutton inmate Hurricane Fly who is better?

Also in the care of Willie Mullins in Closutton, County Carlow is last season’s Champion Bumper winner Champagne Fever. Every indication was that he was going to prove to be substantially better over further than two miles, especially his defeat to Jezki at the start of the season where it looked only a matter of time before he was stepped up in trip on his way to Cheltenham for either the Neptune or Albert Bartlett novice hurdles. Yet on his first run over two-and-a-half miles he ran deplorably although that was down to a respiratory tract infection discovered subsequently. Understandably Willie Mullins gave him a reasonable break to recover from his illness and it was only after apparently impressing in a piece of work that the trainer decided to run him in the Deloitte Novice Hurdle (Leopardstown) on Saturday instead of the aforementioned Un Atout. This was over two miles and two furlongs and was assumed to be Champagne Fever’s prep for the Neptune, especially with the presence of Pique Sous and Mozoltov, alongside Un Atout, as Supreme Novice contenders. Such is the owner’s strength in the novice hurdle divisions, however, he already has leading fancies in the Neptune and Albert Bartlett. With the desire to have a runner in each Festival race, Champagne Fever’s winning form over two miles at Cheltenham and his proximity to long time Supreme Favourite Jezki on just his second start over hurdles, it is hard to argue Rich Ricci’s decision isn’t justified.

During Saturday’s race the fall, at the second, of main rival Waaheb handed Champagne Fever a relatively straightforward task, assuming he was none the worse for his previous infection. Under an aggressive ride from new pilot Paul Townend, this willing son of Stowaway set a tempo likely to expose any weakness in his opposition and bring his strength, stamina, to the fore. Aside from a not insignificant mistake at the first his jumping was accomplished and if he is to try similar tactics in the Supreme his jumping will need to be absolutely foot perfect. Here it nearly was as he took lengths out of his challengers at most obstacles, there is a special chaser in there waiting to get out and it is a shame we didn’t see him over fences this season. All bar Bright New Dawn were left toiling in behind Champagne Fever, whose prodigious galloping was too much for the rest to handle. Bright New Dawn did look a serious danger in on the run up to the last, having travelled sweetly with the guidance of Davy Russell, but the victory was sealed by the gangly grey with another fluent leap at the final flight, as he was always going to outstay his Dessie Hughes trained opponent.

Ruby Walsh has a very tough decision to make as he has the option of riding Dodging Bullets, for Paul Nicholls, and Pique Sous, Mozoltov and now Champagne Fever, for Willie Mullins, in the Supreme. I would suggest he rides Champagne Fever as there is no doubt in my mind that he is the best horse in that foursome, the worry would be whether he will be effective enough over the minimum trip. The Neptune looks made for him but with the presence of the inimitable Pont Alexandre, the Supreme it will have to be. Whether he can reverse early season form with Jezki is highly doubtful and Bright New Dawn gave that horse another boost having been eight lengths behind in the Future Champions Novice Hurdle. There is also the matter of whether Champagne Fever can hold off a number of far speedier types as he is sent for home, but such is his class I suspect there is every chance that he can hold off enough to be right there at the last and whatever happens it will be a tantalising spectacle.

On Sunday, we saw a highly anticipated clash between two more horses that, earlier in the season, I had expected to go down the Neptune novices hurdle route. Melodic Rendezvous and Puffin Billy were both comfortable winners on their last start, winning a grade 1 and a grade 2 respectively. Both are extremely well regarded by connections and both sets were convinced they were going to win at Exeter. Despite Melodic Rendezvous being the grade 1 winner it was Puffin Billy who was sent off the odds on favourite. Oliver Sherwood’s son of Heron Island had looked awesome in two bumpers and two novice hurdles to date, showing a combination of pace and power that marked him out as a danger to all with Cheltenham on the horizon, yet it was the locally trained (to Exeter) Melodic Rendezvous who came out comprehensively on top.

Nick Schofield was under the impression that Puffin Billy was more of a stayer than his mount Melodic Rendezvous. Believing he could beat him for speed Schofield tracked Puffin Billy nearly throughout the contest, only making his challenge at the last. The torrential rain in the morning had left the ground bordering on bottomless but both of the main protagonists in this five runner affair had experience on this sort of surface, as a result it was not expected to inconvenience either and it is hard to say it did. Melodic Rendezvous again jumped well throughout, he is a natural hurdler, and Puffin Billy seemingly improved his hurdling technique but one serious blunder two out probably sealed his fate. At the last the two were side by side but Leighton Aspell had been hard at Puffin Billy for most of the straight whilst Nick Schofield had been motionless on Melodic Rendezvous. Once asked he quickened away instantly, leaving the struggling Puffin Billy for dead. On the face of it this was an exciting performance from a progressive novice and he has definitely improved physically through the season (compared to when I saw him at Cheltenham anyway) but the manner in which Puffin Billy made such hard work of it from so far out suggested that there was something amiss with him and he was later discovered to be lame, thus explaining the lack of correlation between how he had run up until then and how he ran on Sunday.

It is far from ideal for Puffin Billy and his connections’ Cheltenham aspirations to run such a lacklustre race so near to the Festival but it would be wrong to judge him on this performance and he is still a hugely promising horse. It would also, therefore, be wrong to draw too many hard and fast conclusions about the winner Melodic Rendezvous. What I can reiterate is that he jumps well and he clearly has a dangerous turn of foot but he is yet to show me that he has the star potential that will be necessary to win this season’s Supreme. I was concerned after his grade 1 win that I could be underestimating him, and that is still the case but it is just too easy to knock the Tolworth form, while he was lucky in my opinion to win at Cheltenham and on hurdling debut he was defeated by Mr Mole who has just won a minor handicap off a mark of 126. Now, that fails to tell the whole story as Mr Mole is another promising sort who won emphatically but that has to be a concern for Melodic Rendezvous supporters, especially as it was on the quickest ground he has faced over hurdles. Were Cheltenham to be heavy I think he would suddenly become an interesting player but I expect he will struggle on a sounder surface against the calibre of opposition expected at the Festival.

Following Sunday’s win bookmakers shortened up Melodic Rendezvous into 8/1 generally for the Supreme Novices’ Hurdle. This was an overreaction especially as his only rival in the listed race was pronounced lame soon after. With a foot problem diagnosed and confirmed later this race at Exeter was an uninformative contest. It should not have affected his price to such an extent, I see him as a 12/1 shot at best especially when there are murmurings that he could switch to the Neptune on quicker ground.